How to prepare dinner the proper risotto nero | Life and elegance


Risotto al nero di seppia is a Venetian basic that mixes 2 of La Serenissima’s favorite elements: rice and seafood from the lagoon. The ink – usually harvested from the extra generously equipped cuttlefish than the squid that’s typically most well-liked in English variations – offers the rice a creamy, distinctly maritime richness that pairs fantastically with the sweetness of the cephalopod.

The dish’s wider reputation is, I believe, as a lot right down to its putting look as its pretty flavour: few cooks can resist the temptation of a jet-black canvas for his or her inventive thrives. My drawback is that, every time I make it at house, it seems an unappetising dirty-grey color. So, what’s the secret to creating risotto nero that appears nearly as good because it tastes?

The cephalopods

Although risotto nero within the Veneto tends to be made with cuttlefish in addition to their ink, lots of the recipes I take advantage of recommend squid instead. This should be welcome information: whereas well-liked knowledge holds that cuttlefish are less expensive, they show not possible to return by in any of my native fishmongers, despite the fact that they’re flourishing, apparently, in ever-warmer seas. I finally discover them lurking on the backside of a capacious chest freezer behind a Chinese grocery store, beneath the label “squid”.

Eataly's risotto nero

Prawn, to be wild … Eataly’s risotto nero. Photograph: Felicity Cloake for the Guardian

Cuttlefish are sometimes stated to have a stronger, meatier flavour than squid, however I feel the distinction is principally one in every of texture: cuttlefish appear to be sturdier and lack the delicately trailing tentacles which might be one of many predominant sights of their cousins. (The late Alan Davidson’s description of cephalopods as “like bags with heads on top and eight or 10 arms or tentacles sprouting therefrom” is apt.) After per week coping with each, I’ve to confess I favor squid, as a result of it cooks extra rapidly, however use whichever you will get your fingers on – it’s extra essential that they’re small and skinny sufficient to melt in the identical time because the rice (be aware that this can be a dish during which they need to retain some chew, as a distinction with the creamy risotto).

The recipe from Eataly, the worldwide Italian meals corridor chain, makes use of prawns, somewhat than cuttlefish. This might or is probably not a conventional variation, however it appears to make little sense. Given that risotto nero should be made with cuttlefish or squid ink, it might appear extra logical to pair this with the beast that created it.

The Silver Spoon's risotto nero

Distinctly much less creamy … risotto nero by The Silver Spoon. Photograph: Felicity Cloake for the Guardian

The liquid

One benefit of utilizing prawns is that you could produce a inventory from the shells. This makes Eataly’s risotto candy and nuttily scrumptious, though it’s emphatically shrimp-flavoured, somewhat than tasting of cuttlefish. Italian cookery bible The Silver Spoon and Tom Aikens each use fish inventory, Rose Gray and Ruth Rogers’ The River Cafe Classic Italian Cookbook suggests fish inventory or water and Bruce Poole of Chez Bruce in London recommends fish inventory, mild rooster inventory or water.

Chicken is my standard selection for lighter risottos; it imparts a savoury ingredient with out an excessive amount of in the best way of meatiness. Here, although, whereas it actually works, giving Poole’s recipe a chic richness, it doesn’t mix in as seamlessly as The River Cafe’s water, which yields a surprisingly punchy outcome. Best of all, nevertheless, is a delicate fish inventory. Be certain to style it earlier than use, and dilute it additional if it is rather salty or sturdy, as a result of each squid and cuttlefish have a fragile flavour.

Tom Aikens’ risotto nero

Zesty … Tom Aikens’ risotto nero. Photograph: Felicity Cloake for the Guardian

Wine-wise, most risottos use the cool, dry whites of the north-east, though the Eataly cooking technique mentions purple – which is complicated, provided that the elements record specifies white. I determine to present purple a strive anyway, on the premise that it would assist with the color of the dish, however the acidity of white proves extra pleasing and you’ll drink the remainder of the bottle with dinner.

The rice

The River Cafe and Poole name for vialone nano rice, which, because it offers a barely much less creamy outcome than The Silver Spoon’s carnaroli, is extra conventional with fish and seafood. My testers loved each. Arborio is certainly a poor 3rd – much less starchy and extra liable to breaking, it’s the most generally obtainable of the 3, however use both of the others when you’ve got the selection.

The flavourings

All risottos, or not less than all these I’ve come throughout, begin with a flavour base of softly fried alliums. The River Cafe recommends purple onion, Poole and The Silver Spoon white and Eataly and Aikens shallots; everybody however Eataly additionally provides garlic. All of those are nice decisions, however the barely vinous, candy flavour of the shallots appears to have an affinity with the seafood. In any case, garlic is never a foul thought.

The River Cafe's risotto nero

Surprisingly punchy … The River Cafe’s risotto nero. Photograph: Felicity Cloake for the Guardian

Poole and The River Cafe additionally add tomatoes. Despite my preliminary dedication to preserving issues so simple as attainable, I’m received over: they provide a fruity acidity that enhances the wine and is much less strident than Aikens’s lemon juice. I additionally fall, unexpectedly, for his or her dried purple chilli – in spite of everything, Venice was on the traditional spice route, albeit lengthy earlier than chillies made it to the previous world. Perhaps extra traditionally correct is Poole’s star anise, however my testers discovered it too sturdy – it’s advanced and attention-grabbing, however a bit distracting.

Poole’s recipe consists of fennel and celery, too, that are good additions with out being important to the success of the dish. The similar goes for Aikens’s thyme and bay leaf, though I like his lemon zest, which I can be utilizing to complete the dish.

To end

Traditionally, risotto is completed with a giant lump of butter and a few grated cheese, however The River Cafe reckons that, “if you have plenty of the rich, creamy ink, butter is not necessary”. Aikens appears to agree, utilizing creme fraiche as a substitute (however then he has cooked the rice in 75g of the stuff already), whereas Poole provides “slightly less than usual, as the squid ink is rich”, which remains to be virtually twice as a lot as The Silver Spoon suggests. While I’m not typically inclined to show down butter, on this case, trying on the colors of all of the risottos I’ve produced, I’m going to substitute additional ink – and various it, too.

Bruce Poole’s risotto nero

With added gremolata … Bruce Poole’s risotto nero. Photograph: Felicity Cloake for the Guardian

The dish wants nothing extra, however Poole’s gremolata – extra generally related to osso buco – works so properly that I used to be pressured to make extra to cater for my grasping testers. If the concept offends you, be at liberty to skip it, however this garlic-free model provides a zesty, peppery freshness that proves the proper counterpart to the rice.

The technique

Most risotto nero recipes comply with the identical technique as some other risotto, with the notable exception of The Silver Spoon’s, which provides the inventory in a single go and leaves it to do its personal factor, with first rate, if distinctly much less creamy, outcomes. The distinction is available in once they add the seafood: The Silver Spoon braises it for 20 minutes in wine and water earlier than including the rice; The River Cafe provides it simply earlier than the rice; and Poole and Aikens pop it in on the finish of cooking, with Poole sautéing it first. This is why it is very important use small squid or cuttlefish – after 25 minutes of gradual simmering, they are going to be simply tender, with sufficient texture to not be misplaced within the rice, and could have given up their scrumptious flavour within the course of.

Perfect risotto nero

Serves 2 as a predominant course, 4 as a starter

1 tbsp olive oil
1 tbsp butter
1 banana shallot, 2 spherical ones or ½ white onion, finely chopped
1 garlic clove, finely chopped
Pinch of chilli flakes (non-obligatory)
400g child squid or cuttlefish, cleaned (reserve any ink in case you are shopping for them contemporary), tentacles separated, our bodies chopped into small rings
1l fish inventory
175g risotto rice, ideally vialone nano, however carnaroli will work
75ml dry white wine
2 medium tomatoes, contemporary or tinned, chopped
3 sachets of cuttlefish ink
Zest of 1 lemon, finely grated
2 tbsp finely chopped flat-leaf parsley

Heat the oil and butter in a large, pretty high-sided pan over a medium warmth. Cook the shallots till smooth, however not brown, then stir within the garlic and chilli flakes, if utilizing, and proceed to prepare dinner for a few minutes. Meanwhile, put the inventory in a 2nd pan and produce to a gradual simmer.

Add the seafood to the shallot pan and stir to mix, then add the rice and season. Cook for a few minutes, stirring to coat with the fats, till the perimeters of the grains of rice start to show translucent.

Turn up the warmth barely, then add the wine and tomatoes. Cook, stirring, till a lot of the liquid has been absorbed, then stir in one of many sachets of ink. When that is evenly distributed within the rice, start stirring within the scorching inventory, a ladleful at a time, ready till the rice has absorbed a lot of the liquid earlier than including extra, and stirring usually. How lengthy it will take relies on how al dente or in any other case you want your rice, however reckon on 20 to 26 minutes.

When the rice is sort of finished, stir in as a lot of the remaining ink as it’s essential to give the dish color, then season to style. Combine the lemon zest and parsley and sprinkle excessive to serve.

Risotto nero: a triumph of fashion and substance or a dish that doesn’t float your fishing boat? Is squid simply nearly as good as cuttlefish right here or is it price in search of out the actual factor? Is chilli sacrilege? Which different elements are you craving after getting back from vacation?

Felicity Cloake from

Leave a Reply